Why don’t the MAGA people take down their Trump signs? Why do they still support Trump when he is deporting innocent people, attacking colleges, and illegally firing government workers?
Have you personally been harmed by any of the Trump policies? I seriously doubt if anyone who reads this post has been laid off, is in danger of being deported, or has been harassed by the police. Perhaps your 401k has lost some money, but if you are like me, nothing in your day-to-day life has changed since Trump took office.
Certainly you are bothered by the cruelty, the lies, the whole tariff business, the clampdown on colleges, the cravenness of large law firms, and the incompetents running government agencies, but that is because you are a good citizen, you care about America and its place in the world, and you can’t sleep at night.
Now think about the average MAGA voter. Where does he get his info? What does he know about tariffs? Can he find Greenland on a map? Does he know about the Associated Press being kept out of briefings? Does he know what the Associated Press is?
The latest issue of The Atlantic has an article entitled “A Warning Out of Time.” It discusses a book by Ernst Fraenkel, a German-Jewish attorney who got out in 1938 and two years later published The Dual State. Fraenkel noted that the Nazis did not end the day-to-day legal system. The country still had traffic laws, normal criminal procedures, normal police enforcement.
At the same time the government established a separate system of state lawlessness and arbitrary rules, BUT ONLY FOR CERTAIN PEOPLE. If you were not in a targeted group, you may not have noticed anything different in your life.
If you are a billionaire who sat in the front rows of Trump’s inaugural, your business is protected. If you are a farmer in Iowa, you might worry about the tariffs, but you are protected. If you think immigrants are overrunning the country, you may even be pleased that they are being shipped off to a prison in El Salvador without due process. What is due process anyway?
This is why Trump supporters are still flying their flags and keeping their signs up. They like Columbia University getting punished. They like well-paid government employees getting fired. They hear on their news sources that Robert Kennedy, Jr., is recommending inexpensive medicines, and they are delighted.
Fraenkel’s duel state is what is happening in Russia or Hungary today. You don’t need genocide to have a duel state. Just a pliant population that gets the news the leaders feed them on Fox or “X” or Truth Social and isn’t too concerned about the targeted groups who are living in a violent state unchecked by legalities and where ordinary law no longer applies.
You need a significant population who looks about and says “not my problem.” We have that population in America. This is what I find so disturbing and so unexpected.